An inspection commissioned by the Department of Environment, Food and Agriculture questions previous recommendations that Tramway Terrace be demolished.
The property is designated as a Registered Building, and so demolition should only be considered as a last resort.
The new report, by Mann Williams Engineers, says various other reports have either only focused on a small proportion of the building or have been based on comments made by others.
It adds that a report commissioned by the DOI in 2018 advised a number of repairs, which have not been carried out, resulting in further deterioration.
It concludes that a significant proportion of the current condition of the building is a result of failure to repair and maintain this registered building, and says it is repairable.
How much has the Department of Infrastructure claimed for property damage?
Visa fraudster convicted in Isle of Man immigration scam
Crowds gather for Maccies re-opening after £1.6m upgrade
MHK questions wages of 1,500 extra workers
Manxman sailings cancelled today
New parent employment rights to start this Saturday
70% of cars fail police winter roadside checks
Festival of Remembrance at the Villa next month